The Mariners' Second Base Dilemma: To Trade or Not to Trade Luis Arraez?
The Seattle Mariners' second base situation is a topic of much debate as the season approaches. With just under three weeks until pitchers and catchers report to Peoria, the team is considering their options, including the possibility of trading for Luis Arraez.
The Case for Luis Arraez in Seattle
Arraez has spent more time at first base in recent seasons, but his extensive experience at second base and as a designated hitter could be valuable. He is a three-time batting champion and led the NL in hits last season, which could help the Mariners' strikeout problems. Additionally, his low strikeout rate in 2025 and career total of 215 strikeouts in seven years make him an attractive option.
Baseball Savant's data supports this argument, as Arraez ranks in the 100th percentile for K%, Whiff%, and Squared-Up%. However, there has been little buzz surrounding Arraez in general, with MLB.com noting that he has only been a 1-WAR player in the past two seasons.
The Case Against Trading for Luis Arraez
While Arraez has his strengths, some argue that he is overrated. He has been just a 1-WAR player in the past two seasons, and his overall Batting Run Value ranks in the 15th percentile. FanGraphs' Ben Clemons wrote an article in October 2024 about the myth of Arraez improving a lineup by his presence alone.
Additionally, SoDo Mojo's Zachary Rymer argues that Arraez is a lousy slugger, baserunner, and defender. Some projections have him signing for around two years and $24 million, which is affordable to the Mariners, but ultimately, he is not worth the investment. While Cole Young still has questions, he has more upside compared to Arraez.
The Mariners' Dilemma
The Mariners are faced with a difficult decision. On one hand, Arraez has the potential to help with their strikeout problems and provide valuable experience at second base. On the other hand, his lack of power and defensive abilities may not be worth the cost. The team must carefully consider their options and make a decision that best fits their needs and budget.
